Two friends in need of money go into the world's oldest profession. Murray is dealing with the recent closure of his bookshop when his beautiful dermatologist Dr. Parker mentions she's looking for a man to participate in a ménage à trois with her and her equally gorgeous friend Selima. Recognizing the financial potential of her proposal, Murray overcomes Fioravante's reluctance to being his "ho" and the two go into business. Murray procures a second client, Avigal, the widow of a revered Chasidic Rabbi, and Fioravante finds himself falling for her. This unleashes the jealousy of Dovi, who has pined for her since childhood. Before long, Murray discovers it's not so easy to be a pimp and finds out that the secular and the Orthodox must come to a head sooner or later.